Comment replies not nesting when replying from wp-admin/edit-comments page

  • Unknown's avatar

    When I’m handling my comments from the wp-admin/edit-comments.php page, and click the ‘reply’ button, I’ve noticed that my replies are not “nesting” under the comment thread, but instead are appearing as a top-level comment. This is a relatively new issue for me (though I saw it reported back in 2009 when searching the forum).

    The blog I need help with is: (visible only to logged in users)

  • Unknown's avatar

    Could you please send me a link of a comment where you encounter this issue?

  • Unknown's avatar

    Yes, and thank you.
    When I start from this page:
    https://gmoawareness.wordpress.com/wp-admin/edit-comments.php

    And choose the “Reply” link under the comment, everything appears to be functioning properly—as I type the button turns into “Reply and Approve.” However when I happen to view the comments on that page, I see that it did not actually “nest.”

    When I noticed this, I decided to try the alternate form of replying: I approved the comment first, then went directly to the page to click the “Reply” link on the comment itself, and sure enough, the comment “nested” correctly.

    Unfortunately I deleted several examples thinking I was just doing something wrong… so I only have one example left:

    On this page, Anne Dietrich made several comments.
    Her last comment on the page was replied to from the main Administrative Comment page:
    http://gmo-awareness.com/about/
    As you can see, my reply to her appears to be a new comment at the bottom of the page, rather than “nested under” her comment.

    On the same page, her 2nd to the last comment (containing two links) was approved first, then I went directly to the page and hit the “Reply” button, and it nested properly.

    This is my only example, because when I noticed it was happening, I began approving comments first, and going directly to the page to reply.

    Hopefully it was just a temporary hiccup? :-)

  • Unknown's avatar

    I see what you mean. It might have been a glitch though. You can try to remove the comment at https://gmoawareness.wordpress.com/wp-admin/comment.php?action=editcomment&c=30346 (click on the ‘move to trash’ link) and then reply to her comment again the same way as you did before.

  • Unknown's avatar

    Yes, I removed all of the other ones, just left this one so I could do a screenshot if requested. And yes, looks like it was just a 48 hour glitch, as things are working properly again now. Thanks kindly!

  • Unknown's avatar

    Great! Feel free to contact us if you have any other questions.

  • The topic ‘Comment replies not nesting when replying from wp-admin/edit-comments page’ is closed to new replies.